The first photo shows the stock vibration damper. It's some sort of asphalt impregnated cardboard. Most of the time I find these resting on the headliner. It's not a great for performance or durability. It's very easy to peel off. The second photo shows CLD Tiles™ applied. We added a layer of 3M Thinsulate Acoustic but I don't have any pictures of that. We now use 3/4" Hydrophobic Melamine foam as our absorber.